Skip to content
  • Home
  • Services
    • Personal Injury
      • Car Accident Injury
      • Motorcycle Accident Injury
      • Bicycle Accident Injury
      • Pedestrian Accident Injury
      • Slip & Fall Accident Injury
      • In-Flight Injury on Airplanes
      • Child & Infant Injuries
      • Medical & Dental Malpractice
      • Elder Care Negligence & Abuse
      • Dangerous Premises
      • Sexual Abuse
      • Commercial & Social Host Liability
      • Severe Injuries
    • Estate Litigation
    • Insurance Denials
    • Product Liability
    • Class Action
  • Case Studies
    • ICBC / Personal Injury Cases
    • Estate Litigation Cases
  • Community
    • Community Relationships
    • Charitable Giving
  • Legal Resources
    • Sexual Assault Handbook
    • Personal Injury & ICBC Claim Handbook
    • Estate Litigation Handbook
    • Legal Articles
  • About
    • Meet your team
    • Media Centre
    • Legal and Academic Partnerships
  • Contact
Menu
  • Home
  • Services
    • Personal Injury
      • Car Accident Injury
      • Motorcycle Accident Injury
      • Bicycle Accident Injury
      • Pedestrian Accident Injury
      • Slip & Fall Accident Injury
      • In-Flight Injury on Airplanes
      • Child & Infant Injuries
      • Medical & Dental Malpractice
      • Elder Care Negligence & Abuse
      • Dangerous Premises
      • Sexual Abuse
      • Commercial & Social Host Liability
      • Severe Injuries
    • Estate Litigation
    • Insurance Denials
    • Product Liability
    • Class Action
  • Case Studies
    • ICBC / Personal Injury Cases
    • Estate Litigation Cases
  • Community
    • Community Relationships
    • Charitable Giving
  • Legal Resources
    • Sexual Assault Handbook
    • Personal Injury & ICBC Claim Handbook
    • Estate Litigation Handbook
    • Legal Articles
  • About
    • Meet your team
    • Media Centre
    • Legal and Academic Partnerships
  • Contact

*

ICBC CLAIM LIMITS the AND NEW
NO FAULT INSURANCE

Click here

publicly reported cases

Home > Case Studies > Do legal obligations to a spouse compare to moral obligations to a child?

Do legal obligations to a spouse compare to moral obligations to a child?

In Tataryn v. Tataryn, [1994] 2 SCR 807, the will-maker had 2 adult independent children (J and E) and a spouse. The will-maker disliked their son J due to his religious convictions. In the Will, he acknowledged that he was excluding his son due to their strained relationship. The will-maker also left very little to his wife, despite her efforts in being a stay at home mom, due to his fear that she would give his assets to J. The will-maker left his wife a life estate in the matrimonial house and made her the beneficiary of a discretionary trust of the income from the residue of the estate, with their son E as trustee. After her death, everything was to go to E. The spouse and J claimed against the estate under the Wills Variation Act, s. 2(1) (as it was) for a lack of adequate provisions for their proper maintenance and support. This case was appealed up to the Supreme Court of Canada. The judge determined that the wife should have title to the matrimonial home, the rental property (for her lifetime, then to E), and everything else in the estate, other than a cash gift of $10,000 to each son.

HOW DID A LAWYER HELP?

In this case, the will-maker's only legal obligations during his lifetime were toward his wife. This is because they had been in a long marriage in which they both contributed to their joint estate. Had they separated during his lifetime, the wife would have a claim to 50 percent of the estate. The children in this case did not have any specific needs, and since the estate was mostly in the form of real property, a modest gift to them appropriate. It is important to consult with a lawyer to understand the variables that a judge will consider in an estate variation claim. In some circumstances, adult children will have needs that must be accounted for. In others, a spouse may be wholly dependent on the joint estate to survive. Family law legislation cannot be claimed unless a couple has separated before the date of death, and thus estate litigation lawyers will be key in ascertaining the amount owed to a widowed spouse.

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

Here's how our Estate Litigation lawyers can help you.

PUBLICLY REPORTED CASES

Can post-death taxes be considered in will variation claims?

In Ciarniello v. Ciariello Estate, 2016 BCSC 1699, the will-maker and his wife lived together for 39 years. He had five adult children (including three from a previous marriage).

Read More
Helena Teteris

Can you justify disinheritance of adult children in your Will?

In the case of Clucas v. Royal Trust Corporation of Canada, 1999 CanLII 5519 (BCSC), the will-maker acknowledged the potential claim to vary her Will due to the exclusion of her adult child and addressed this in her Will.

Read More
Helena Teteris

What if you favor one beneficiary over another?

Lamperstorfer v. Lamperstorfer Estate, 2018 BCSC 89 involved an action by the children of the deceased to vary their father’s Will. The Will left 25% to each son, 10% to his ex-wife, and the remainder to other relatives who were not around for most of his life.

Read More
Helena Teteris
PrevPreviousCan you justify disinheritance of adult children in your Will?
NextCan post-death taxes be considered in will variation claims?Next
DOWNLOAD THE ESTATE LITIGATION HANDBOOK

Helpforme was created so that the focus from start to finish is on you and your needs.

Meet Your team
your wellbeing is our priority.
We take a personalized approach to each client’s situation. As for legal fees, we take claims on a contingency basis wherever possible. We’ll support you through every step of your claim.

Contact Us

we are pleased to offer you legal services in these additional languages:

Mandarin

Cantonese

Vietnamese

Farsi

Get Directions

Add Waypoint
show options hide options
Print directions Reset directions
Fetching directions......
Reset directions
Print directions
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube Linkedin
© 2022 Hammerco Lawyers LLP. All Rights Reserved.

Designed by My Loud Speaker

Be stronger when accidents happen. Our app guides you through every step of the way.
Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

Designed by My Loud Speaker